Orijen and Acana are both made by Champion Petfoods, offering premium nutrition with a "Biologically Appropriate" philosophy. Understanding the differences helps you decide if Orijen's premium is worth it over Acana.
Brand Overview
Orijen
- Position: Ultra-premium
- Philosophy: "Biologically Appropriate" - mirrors natural diet
- Protein Content: 38-42%
- Price Point: $$$$
- Meat Content: 85% animal ingredients
Acana
- Position: Premium
- Philosophy: "Biologically Appropriate" - more moderate
- Protein Content: 29-35%
- Price Point: $$$ - $$$$
- Meat Content: 50-75% animal ingredients
Quick Comparison
| Factor | Orijen | Acana |
|---|---|---|
| Average Rating | 4.7/5 | 4.6/5 |
| Price (25 lb) | $85-100 | $65-80 |
| Protein | 38-42% | 29-35% |
| Animal Ingredients | 85% | 50-75% |
| Carbohydrates | Very low | Low |
| Made in | USA & Canada | USA & Canada |
The Champion Petfoods Philosophy
Both brands share:
- Fresh/Raw Ingredients: Never frozen before use
- WholePrey Ratios: Include organs and cartilage
- Regional Sourcing: Ingredients from trusted suppliers
- Single Kitchen: Complete control over production
The difference is Orijen takes this philosophy to the extreme.
Ingredient Comparison
Orijen
- 85% animal ingredients
- Multiple animal protein sources (5-8)
- 2/3 fresh or raw meat
- 1/3 dehydrated meat
- Very limited carbohydrates (15%)
- Freeze-dried coating
Acana
- 50-75% animal ingredients
- Multiple protein sources (3-5)
- Fresh and dehydrated meats
- More carbohydrates than Orijen
- Whole grains available in some lines
- Still high-quality
Nutritional Comparison
Protein
- Orijen: 38-42%
- Acana: 29-35%
- Orijen is significantly higher
Fat
- Orijen: 18-20%
- Acana: 15-17%
- Orijen has more fat for energy
Carbohydrates
- Orijen: ~15-20%
- Acana: ~25-35%
- Orijen is more meat-focused
Product Lines
Orijen
- Original: Signature poultry blend
- Six Fish: Fish-based
- Regional Red: Red meat
- Tundra: Game meats
- Puppy/Senior: Life stages
- Fit & Trim: Weight management
Acana
- Regionals: Heritage, Wild Atlantic, etc.
- Singles: Limited ingredient
- Classics: More affordable line
- Highest Protein: Closer to Orijen
- Puppy/Senior: Life stages
- Wholesome Grains: Grain-inclusive options
Acana offers more variety and price points.
Price Comparison
Per 25 lb Bag
- Orijen Original: $85-100
- Acana Regionals: $65-80
- Acana Singles: $70-85
Orijen costs approximately 25-35% more than Acana.
Who Benefits From Each
Orijen Is Best For
- Very active/working dogs
- Dogs needing maximum protein
- Owners wanting highest meat content
- Dogs thriving on high-protein diets
- Budget is not a constraint
Acana Is Best For
- Most adult dogs
- Those wanting premium at better value
- Dogs not needing extreme protein
- Variety seekers (more options)
- Budget-conscious premium buyers
Important Considerations
Grain-Free and DCM
Both Orijen and Acana have faced scrutiny:
- Both were mentioned in FDA DCM investigation
- Both now offer grain-inclusive options
- Acana Wholesome Grains addresses concerns
- Consult your vet about grain-free feeding
Very High Protein
- Not all dogs need 40% protein
- Can be too rich for some dogs
- May cause digestive upset
- Match protein to activity level
Our Verdict
For Maximum Nutrition
Orijen provides:
- Highest meat content
- Maximum protein
- Ultra-premium quality
- Worth it for dogs who need it
For Premium Value
Acana offers:
- Excellent quality
- Better price point
- More variety
- Sufficient for most dogs
The Honest Truth
Most dogs don't need Orijen's extreme protein levels. Acana provides excellent nutrition at 25-35% lower cost. Save Orijen for very active dogs who truly benefit from maximum protein.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Orijen worth the extra cost?
For highly active dogs, working dogs, or dogs thriving on very high protein, possibly. For average pets, Acana provides excellent nutrition at better value. The extra cost doesn't benefit most dogs.
Are they the same company?
Yes, Champion Petfoods makes both. Same philosophy, same quality standards—Orijen is simply the more extreme version.
Which is better for puppies?
Both have puppy formulas. Acana Puppy is excellent for most puppies. Orijen Puppy is very high protein—may be too rich for some. Large breed puppies should be especially careful with protein levels.
Is 40% protein too much?
For most dogs, it's more than necessary. Very active dogs utilize high protein well. Sedentary dogs may not need it and could have digestive issues. Match protein to lifestyle.
Which is safer regarding DCM concerns?
Both have grain-inclusive options now (Acana Wholesome Grains). These may be safer than grain-free versions. Consult your veterinarian.